Recording HOA meeting may seem like a good idea, but it is not automatically permitted. There are several principles and laws to consider, whether it is a board member or a homeowner who wishes to record the meeting. It will also depend on the type of meeting and the manner of recording.
Is Recording an HOA Meeting Allowed in Texas?
In Texas, there is no blanket law that expressly gives board members or homeowners the right to record an HOA meeting, be it in audio or video form. The law only specifically grants audio recording rights for certain hearings, such as enforcement hearings and architectural appeal hearings.
For other meeting types, the answer will depend on the association’s governing documents and meeting rules. It also matters if the meeting is open to members or not.
Is Recording HOA Annual Meetings Allowed in Texas?
Texas law does not expressly grant owners or associations the right to make an audio or video recording of the HOA annual meeting. That said, annual meetings are open to all homeowners, and many boards permit owners to record the meetings unless it constitutes disruptive behavior.
It is also important to note that Texas is a one-party consent state for audio recordings. This means that someone participating in the conversation can generally record it without getting everyone’s permission.
As for video recordings, the law is not as clear. Yet an HOA may enforce reasonable rules governing camera placement, equipment, and the recording of private information. If the process of recording video is too disruptive, the association may choose to prohibit it in writing.
Is Recording HOA Board Meeting Allowed in Texas?
Texas law is also silent on recording restrictions for HOA board meetings. While board meetings must be open to all members (except for executive sessions), there is no statute that expressly allows audio or video recordings.
In practice, many associations allow audio recordings of open board meetings. Some associations may also allow video recordings, but with more limitations. There are also HOAs or condos that permit recordings only with advance notice.
That said, Texas law does require written minutes and meeting records (Section 209.0051).
Can You Record HOA Executive Sessions in Texas?
Executive sessions are unique in that homeowners don’t have a right to attend them. Texas law allows closed board meetings, but only to discuss certain topics. Owners can only join the meeting if the board extends an invitation.
Because executive sessions are confidential, owners usually can’t record them. Boards often prohibit even board members from recording executive sessions without authorization. This makes sense, as unauthorized recordings could raise confidentiality concerns.
Is Recording HOA Architectural Appeal Hearings Allowed in Texas?
Texas law is more explicit regarding architectural appeal hearings. According to Section 209.00505, both the HOA and the owner can make an audio recording of a hearing related to an architectural review denial.
If a homeowner appeals a denial to the board or architectural committee, either party may record the hearing. This only applies to audio recordings. The statute does not address video recordings.
That said, recording an HOA meeting related to an architectural appeal is not mandatory. The HOA or the homeowner has the option to do so. The law also doesn’t require the association to automatically provide copies of recordings.
Can You Record HOA Enforcement Hearings in Texas?
As per Section 209.007 of the Texas Property Code, both the HOA and the homeowner have the right to audio-record enforcement hearings. As with ARC appeal recordings, either party may do this, but it is limited to audio. The statute does not address video recordings.
Enforcement hearings, otherwise known as disciplinary hearings, give owners a chance to defend their case against an alleged violation. If an owner requests this hearing, they may choose to record the meeting. The HOA also has this option.
Is it Legal to Record an HOA Meeting? Audio vs Video Recording Explained
Whether or not recording an HOA meeting is legal depends on the type of meeting and the medium. Audio and video recordings generally have differing regulations.
Audio Recording
Texas is generally a one-party consent state under Texas Penal Code Section 16.02. Recording an audio conversation, including an HOA meeting, is typically permitted. That said, the person making the recording must be a participant or get the consent of a participant in the conversation.
This is one reason audio recordings at open meetings are often harder for HOAs to prohibit outright. If an HOA wishes to restrict audio recordings outside of enforcement and architectural hearings, the board must consult legal counsel first. This way, it can ensure that it doesn’t breach any rights or laws.
Video Recording
Video recordings are more complex. They bring additional issues, such as privacy concerns, filming of non-participants, potential intimidation claims, and distribution on social media. Because Texas HOA statutes do not expressly protect video recording rights, associations have more room to regulate video recordings through meeting policies.
Common Rules When Recording HOA Meetings
Many homeowners wish to record meetings for transparency purposes, whereas boards may want to do so for documentation. It is important to balance these desires with the need to protect the privacy of participants. After all, not everyone wants to be caught on record.
Here are the rules that many associations adopt.
- Notice Requirement. An association may require advance notice before the meeting. Homeowners must inform the board or manager in writing at least 24 to 48 hours prior. This also gives the board a chance to announce the recording at the start of the meeting.
- No Disruptions. Many associations prohibit recordings that would disturb the meeting. This means no moving around while filming, no bright lighting, no loud devices, and no blocking of entryways.
- Open Meetings Only. Some associations limit recordings to open meetings, expressly prohibiting recording executive sessions.
- No Recording of Private Conversations. People may participate in private conversations during breaks or side discussions. The HOA may prohibit recording these, as they come with certain privacy expectations.
- No Harassment or Intimidation. Associations may prohibit practices that target or intimidate individuals. This includes excessive zooming on participants, following people with cameras, and recording people who aren’t speaking.
- Distribution Restrictions. Many HOAs don’t allow recordings to be posted online or distributed to others in any form. Commercial use is also usually restricted.
A Balancing Act
Navigating the recording of HOA meetings can be quite tricky, especially when there is a call for increased transparency. Board members must ensure compliance with state laws and the governing documents while navigating regulations governing member behavior.
PAMco offers exceptional HOA management services to communities in Central Texas. Call us today at 512-918-8100 or contact us online to learn more!
RELATED ARTICLES:
